I like to think of my exes in the past tense -- mistakes made, bodies buried, lessons learned. But recently an ex-boyfriend e-mailed me after decades of silence, bringing back memories and the ultimate unanswered question: Why wasn't I the one?
As soon as I received his note, I told my husband about it, and he immediately imagined this old boyfriend was happily married. I resisted. "No way," I said. "I'd bet the house on it. This guy will never marry anyone. He couldn't commit."
Guess what? One wedding and two daughters later, he's as committed as they come. He just couldn't commit to me.
And why should he have? I was in college, unformed and needy with a capital N. Insatiable in my appetite to learn who I was by looking at myself through someone else's eyes. Never satisfied with what I saw there.
It all makes sense now, of course. But at the time, all I could think was: What am I doing wrong?
I spilled a lot of tears and ink over that question.
I agonized and analyzed every look, every gesture, every word for a sign: When did I lose him? At what exact moment did passion turn into indifference?
"Sex and the City"'s Carrie Bradshaw captured it best, after her boyfriend broke up with her on a Post-It note. "Men can get out of a relationship without a goodbye," she wrote, "but apparently women have to either get married or learn something. Why are we in such a rush to move from confused to Confucius?"
If knowledge is power, then I had to know what went wrong so I'd have more power to make it right the next time around. I had to walk away with more than a broken heart.
I wanted to turn myself into Ms. Right so that when my ship came in, we'd sail straight to Honeymoon Island -- or, at least I'd sense it veering off course.
And in my next relationship, I did turn myself around. I was hypervigilant about my independence, ruthless about maintaining my identity. In fact, I didn't need my boyfriend at all. Which is probably why I broke up with him after a few months.
We stayed friends, so I know he didn't spend much time asking himself what he did wrong. He was smart enough to know it wasn't about him. And the truth is, it never is.
Relationships don't end because of one person or one wrong move. They end because they were never intended to last. Just as the clothes I wore in high school no longer fit, and the summer job I had would no longer sustain me, the boys and men I once knew were in my life to be outgrown.
They were with me as I tried and erred, as I failed and succeeded. They showed me who I was and who I wanted to become. They helped me learn to love and hate and to laugh and cry and to understand the difference between fate and fantasy.
So, thank you. Thank you Bruno and Jimmy and Mitch and Dan and Steve. Thank you for preparing me, so that I'd know when the real thing came along -- the easy guy, the one who always makes me laugh and almost never makes me cry. The one who loves me with his whole heart and holds nothing back. The one who is safe and exciting. The one. The one who didn't make me wonder whether I was the one for him.
This LifeFiles column originally appeared on about 70 TV station websites managed by Internet Broadcasting Systems.