There's no question that Colter inherited whatever perfectionist tendency caused him to feel disappointed when he learned yesterday that he made the honor roll but not the principal's list. The question is whether this inheritance was given to him by nature or nurture. In other words, is it in my genes or in myself?
There is evidence that suggests there is a link between perfectionism and giftedness. Perfectionism is one of the many ways in which "giftedness" is less "gift" than it might seem.
Over the years we've come to understand that Colter's giftedness means mostly that he processes the world differently, and this style of thinking is almost definitely biological even though it manifests itself in seemingly psychological symptoms.
But I have to be honest -- I'm not a very good model of mediocrity. Although I expect totally reasonable things of my son, I expect unreasonable things of myself. So, no matter how often I told Colter I was proud of him, he probably sensed (each time) the hypocrisy: I would not have been satisfied if it had been me who landed on the honor roll and not the principal's list.
In a commencement speech she delivered at Mt. Holyoke College, Anna Quindlen -- one of my favorite writers -- offered what may be the most compelling reason I've heard to give up on the holy grail of perfection.
...another reason that you must give up on being perfect and take hold of being yourself is because sometime, in the distant future, you may want to be parents, too. If you can bring to your children the self that you truly are, as opposed to some amalgam of manners and mannerisms, expectations and fears that you have acquired as a carapace along the way, you will give them, too, a great gift. You will teach them by example not to be terrorized by the narrow and parsimonious expectations of the world, a world that often likes to color within the lines when a spray of paint, a scrawl of crayon, is what is truly wanted.
I want Colter to draw the world as he sees it. I want him to be able to look at his drawing of the world and appreciate it. I want him to enjoy his successes and learn from his failures. So, I must do the same.
Any advice for this recovering perfectionist?